I know everyone hates ads. But please understand that I am providing premium content for free that takes hundreds of hours of time to research and write. If I can't make at least a little bit of money to support my family via this site, I'll have to stop working on it.
One alternative is to become a RuneScoop member. It's cheap, you get access to all of the site with no ads, and you help keep the lights on around here.
If you want to use this site for free, I'd be grateful if you could add RuneScoop to the whitelist for Adblock. To do so, just open the Adblock menu and select "Disable on Runescoop.com". Or go to the Tools menu and select "Adblock Plus Preferences...". Then click "Add Filter..." at the bottom, and add this string: "@@http://*runescoop.com/*". Then just click OK.
Thanks for your understanding!
Sincerely... Qeltar, aka Charles, your hard-working host and RuneScape guide-writer extraordinaire. :)
WARNING: This site is intended for online use only; mass-downloading of pages degrades the server and is prohibited. If you attempt to use tools to mass-download the site, you may be blocked permanently by automated software.
Sponsored links help make RuneScoop possible; RuneScoop members don't see them. See here for more information about ads.
All information based on Grand Exchange price data from: May 20, 2012. Note that the three-day delay in price updates is waived for RuneScoop members.
Herblore
Finishing Potions - Combat
Level 36
General Description: Finishing combat potions.
Creation/Revision Date: December 12, 2009
Skill Requirements: Herblore(36)
Quest Requirements: --
Equipment Requirements: --
Other Requirements: --
Additional Info: --
Level-Specific Activity Details (P2P)
Level 36-46 (P2P)
Level 47+ (P2P)
Description
Finishing combat potions at Castle Wars Bank.
Finishing combat potions at Castle Wars Bank using a magpie familiar.
Location
Castle Wars Bank
Castle Wars Bank
Multitasking Suitability
2
2
Level-Specific Requirements
--
--
Activity Parameters (As Evaluated for Skill and Level)
Skills
Herblore(36-46)
Herblore(47+), Summoning(47)
Quests
--
--
Equipment
--
--
Familiar
--
Magpie
Other
--
--
Input and Output Items and Values
Total Input Value
1,076,060 gp
1,078,843 gp
Input Items and Item Values
Harralander potion (unf)[1,730]
249,120
Goat horn dust[1,730]
826,940
Harralander potion (unf)[1,730]
249,120
Goat horn dust[1,730]
826,940
Magpie pouch[1.8]
2,782
Total Output Value
129,750 gp
156,595 gp
Output Items and Item Values
Combat potion (3)[1,730]
129,750
Combat potion (3)[1,730]
129,750
Magpie foragings[1.8]
26,845
Herblore XP
Herblore XP Total
145,320
145,320
Herblore XP by Item
Combat potion (3)[1,730]
145,320
Combat potion (3)[1,730]
145,320
Skill Activity Ratings (Primary Skill)
Skill Activity Speed (SAS, XP/hr)
145,320
145,320
Skill Activity Profitability (SAP, gp/hr)
-946,309
-922,247
Skill Activity Efficiency for 100k gp/hr Opp. Cost (SAE100k)
-7.20
-7.03
Skill Activity Efficiency for 250k gp/hr Opp. Cost (SAE250k)
-8.23
-8.07
Skill Activity Efficiency for 500k gp/hr Opp. Cost (SAE500k)
-9.95
-9.79
Skill Activity Efficiency for 1M gp/hr Opp. Cost (SAE1M)
-13.39
-13.23
Analysis, Discussion and Tips for Success
General Discussion
Finishing potions is a way to get Herblore XP more quickly than making them from scratch, by starting with the herb already in a vial of water, and just adding the secondary ingredient. With standard potions, all of the XP is granted when you add the secondary to finish the potion, so this lets you earn XP about 60% faster. (It's not twice as fast, because the second step is slower than the first, and the second step is a bit faster if you have just made the unfinished potions and they're already in your inventory.)
Of course, nobody wants to waste time putting herbs in water to get no XP unless there's a financial reward. This means that usually, an unfinished potion costs more than a vial of water and an herb. When that is not the case -- because the GE is not updating prices properly -- so many herblorists are trying to buy the unfinished potion that you can't get any. So beware of this before planning to do a lot of leveling this way.
Combat potions combine the effects of regular attack and strength potions, boosting both stats by 10% of your level, rounded down, plus 3 (so 3 to 12 points). The ability to have both effects in one potion is a convenience that some players appreciate, and these can be more economical to make than both attack and strength potions separately.
Location and Access
You can make potions at any bank, but a one-click bank like Castle Wars is preferred.
Required and Recommended Equipment
No equipment is needed.
Required and Recommended Supplies
No supplies are required, aside from unfinished potions and secondary ingredients.
Familiar Suggestions
Summon a foraging familiar to earn extra money for you while you work -- I prefer the magpie, given the high value of rings and gems today. There isn't a really worthwhile forager below Summoning level 47, so I wouldn't bother with a familiar at lower levels.
Technique and Tips
Take out 14 unfinished harralander potions and 14 goat horn dust. Click one vial and then one dust, right-click the main message area and choose "Make All". Wait for the potions to be made, then bank and repeat.
All information based on Grand Exchange price data from: May 20, 2012. Note that the three-day delay in price updates is waived for RuneScoop members.
All information based on Grand Exchange price data from: May 20, 2012. Note that the three-day delay in price updates is waived for RuneScoop members. 
